10 Best Italian Restaurants in Buffalo NY (2023)

Buffalo NY is a city renowned for its warm hospitality and delicious cuisine. This article explores the ten best Italian restaurants in Buffalo NY. You can indulge in Mulberry Meatballs and Chicken Milanese, among other mouthwatering delights, at these top-notch restaurants that cater to your cravings day and night. Join us on this delightful culinary journey!

Italian Restaurants in Buffalo NY

Here are the ten best restaurants in Buffalo NY well-known for their delicious Italian dishes:

1. Mulberry Italian Ristorante

Discover Mulberry Italian Ristorante, a gem in Buffalo, NY, offering genuine Italian cuisine. Delight in their quality ingredients, handmade caprese, and homemade pasta. Must-try dishes include the flavorful Mulberry Meatball, cooked to perfection with authentic ingredients, and the fresh Chicken Parmigiana, hand-cut and served with pasta.

• Address: 164 Jackson Ave, Buffalo, NY 14218
• Phone: (716) 822-4292

2. Lombardo Ristorante

Lombardo Ristorante ranks second among the ten best Italian restaurants in Buffalo NY. Since 1975, Lombardo has been impressing customers with their seasonally changing menu that showcases regional Italian flavors and local ingredients. With a wood-fired oven at the heart of their kitchen, Lombardo Ristorante crafts mouthwatering dishes like wood-fired pizza, organic chicken saltimbocca, and fresh pasta – all made from scratch with love and expertise.

• Address: 1198 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
• Phone: (716) 873-4291

3. Chef’s

Discover Chef’s, a beloved Italian restaurant in Buffalo, NY, known for over 50 years of serving authentic Italian cuisine. Delight in their finest traditional Italian dishes, including soups, salads, entrees, and delectable desserts. Chef’s top-notch waitstaff offers take-out and catering services.

Must-try items include the savory Buffalo Tenders tossed in homemade buffalo wing sauce and the creamy Fettuccine Alfredo Pasta with garlic and fresh parmesan cheese. An excellent choice for a satisfying Italian dining experience.

• Address: 291 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14204
• Phone: (716) 856-9187

4. Tappo Restaurant

Discover a taste of Italy at Tappo Restaurant, a charming Italian eatery located on Ellicott Street in downtown Buffalo, NY. The restaurant boasts a delightful ambiance, authentic Italian wines, and mouthwatering dishes. The polished oak flooring, cozy red leather booths, and friendly wait staff create a welcoming atmosphere. Notably, their Eggplant Parmigiana is a must-try, featuring layers of eggplant, tomato sauce, fresh basil, and melted mozzarella. However, Tappo Restaurant also falls among the ten best Italian restaurants in Buffalo NY.

• Address: 338 Ellicott St, Buffalo, NY 14203
• Phone: (716) 259-8130

5. Osteria 166

If you’re in Buffalo, NY, and craving authentic Italian cuisine, Osteria 166 is the place to be. Established in 2013, Osteria 166 offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere with excellent service. The menu boasts a variety of traditional Italian classics, including sandwiches, pizzas, soups, and salads, catering to all tastes. Don’t miss their Burrata Cheese, a delightful blend of cheese, fresh veggies, fruits, and balsamic vinegar. Another must-try is the Carbonara, made with house-cured pancetta, black pepper, and bucatini noodles, resulting in a silky and creamy delight.

• Address: 166 Franklin St, Buffalo, NY 14202
• Phone: (716) 858-3118

6. Salvatore’s Italian Prime

This renowned restaurant has been delivering excellent service and hospitality since 1938. Indulge in delicious traditional Italian dishes such as osso buco, marsala, rollatini, and roast Long Island ducks. For steak lovers, they offer Buffalo’s finest steaks, particularly their mouthwatering Prime steak, known for its incredible juiciness, flavor, and tenderness with top-notch marbling. However, Salvatore’s Italian Prime ranks sixth among the top Italian restaurants in Buffalo NY.

• Address: 6461 Transit Rd, Buffalo, NY 14043
• Phone: (716) 635-9000

7. Frankie Primo’s +39

Discover Frankie Primo’s +39, a family-owned Italian restaurant on Chippewa Street in Buffalo, NY. The eatery offers a contemporary rustic ambiance and a menu featuring appetizers. These appetizers include fried calamari and scampi, and entrees such as gnocchi with Pomodoro sauce and flavorful pizzas. Don’t miss their popular dishes like Tagliatelle Funghi, a creamy pasta with truffle cream sauce and fresh mushrooms, and Pappardelle made with slow-braised pork, chianti, tomatoes, cheese, and hazelnuts.

• Address: 51 W Chippewa St, Buffalo, NY 14202
• Phone: (716) 855-3739

8. Trattoria Aroma

Trattoria Aroma-Williamsville is a must-visit eatery if you’re looking for authentic Italian cuisine in Buffalo, NY. With over 20 years of experience, Trattoria Aroma is known for its homemade specialties made from scratch and a welcoming atmosphere. Trattoria Aroma has an impressive selection of Italian wines and delectable sweets like Tiramisu and Biscotti.

For the best pasta in town, try Trattoria Aroma’s Frutti Di Mare, featuring homemade spaghetti with a delightful combination of sea scallops, mussels, calamari, tiger shrimp, and clams, seasoned with spicy pomodoro and fresh basil.

• Address: 307 Bryant St, Buffalo, NY 14222
• Phone: (716) 881-75929

9. Sinatra’s

Sinatra’s is one of the best Italian restaurants in Buffalo NY. Looking for a top-notch Italian restaurant in Buffalo? Renowned for its Sicilian and Southern Italian cuisine, the house sauce adds a unique touch to dishes like lasagna and meatballs. Indulge in delicious options such as Gnocchi Puttanesca, bursting with flavors, or the smoky Lamb Chops, marinated in garlic and herbs to perfection.

• Address: 945 Kenmore Ave, Buffalo, NY 14223
• Phone: (716) 877-9419

10. Romeo & Juliet’s Bakery & Cafe

If you’re looking for a top-notch Italian restaurant with a warm and welcoming atmosphere, we highly recommend Romeo & Juliet’s Bakery & Cafe. They have been delighting customers since 1998 with genuine, high-quality cuisine. Romeo & Juliet’s Bakery & Café’s menu features daily specials and heart-healthy options to cater to diverse tastes. Don’t miss their delicious Lasagne Bolognese made with ground beef, ricotta, and lasagna, and topped with mozzarella, served with sauteed green beans.

• Address: 1292 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
• Phone: (716) 873-5730

Conclusion

Looking for the best Italian food in Buffalo? We’ve got you covered! Simply go through the article above to see the ten best Italian restaurants in Buffalo NY. From the classic and renowned Salvatore’s Italian Gardens to the time-tested San Marco Ristorante, we’ve got options that’ll satisfy your cravings. Don’t miss the recently-opened Tappo, a trendy space in a historic downtown building, or the mouthwatering Italian subs at Marco’s Italian Deli.