10 Leading Italian Restaurants in St Augustine (2023)

You can discover the ten top Italian restaurants in St Augustine, where you can indulge in authentic Italian cuisine and experience the flavors of Italy. From mouthwatering pizzas to creamy Alfredo pasta, these restaurants offer a variety of traditional dishes that will satisfy your cravings. Immerse yourself in the taste of Italy and enjoy a truly delicious dining experience. Read down carefully to get informed.

Italian Restaurants in St Augustine

These are the ten best restaurants in St Augustine popular for delivering Italian cuisine among other cuisines:

1. Pizzalley’s Chianti Room

Pizzalley’s Chianti Room in St. Augustine offers an authentic Italian dining experience with brick oven pizzas, flavorful dishes, and a wide selection of Italian wines. Their restaurant ambiance takes you on a journey to Italy, starting from their alleyway entrance to a secluded courtyard and dining room.

Pizzalley’s Chianti Room ranks first among the ten leading Italian restaurants in St Augustine. This restaurant is known for its award-winning pizza, homemade recipes, and fresh ingredients. Also, they have received recognition for their exceptional service and high-quality food.

• Opening Hours: Sun-Thurs: 11:30 am – 8 pm; Fri: 11:30 am – 9 pm; Sat: 11:30 am – 10 pm
• Location: 60 Charlotte Street, St. Augustine, FL 32084

2. Nonna’s Trattoria

Nonna’s Trattoria is a delightful restaurant that serves flavorful dishes prepared with love. They make fresh homemade sauces daily and use high-quality ingredients from local farmers. With an experienced chef and a unique menu featuring Italian and Floridian fusion dishes, Nonna’s ensures a memorable dining experience. Enjoy their outdoor seating that captures the essence of dining in an Italian city.

• Opening Hours: Mon & Tues: Closed; Wed-Sun: 5 pm – 10 pm
• Location: 2 Aviles Street, St. Augustine, FL 32084

3. Pizzalley’s on St. George

Pizzalley’s on St. George Street is a charming Italian pizzeria in St. Augustine. They offer various pizza options, from customizable slices to gourmet pies. Pizzalley’s on St. George also serves wings, chicken tenders, and delicious desserts like homemade brownies and fried cheesecake.

The ambiance is inspired by Italy, with brick walls and Italian-themed decor. It’s a must-visit spot for pizza lovers exploring historic St. George Street. Pizzalley’s on St. George also appears among the ten top Italian restaurants in St Augustine.

• Opening Hours: Sun-Sat: 11 am – 8 pm
• Location: 117 St George Street, St. Augustine, FL 32084

4. Terra & Acqua

Terra & Acqua is a St. Augustine Italian restaurant specializing in the flavors of the Tuscan coast. With a Florence-native chef, they serve modern Italian dishes like charred octopus and rib-eye, offering flavors from both land and sea. Enjoy cocktails, draft beer, and wine, and dine on their patio for a scenic experience. Head to Terra & Acqua for a casual, modern, Italian dining experience.

• Opening Hours: Sun – Thurs: 4 pm – 9 pm, Fri & Sat: 4 pm – 10 pm
• Location: 134 Sea Grove Main Street, St. Augustine Beach, FL 32080

5. Vinny’s Pizza

Vinny’s Pizza, a local, family-owned pizzeria, offers delicious Italian comfort food like pizza, subs, and calzones. They provide coupons on their website and free garlic knots with a purchase of their 18″ pizzas. Vinny’s also serves ravioli, gyros, wraps and aims to offer an authentic Italian dining experience. However, Vinny’s Pizza ranks fifth among the ten leading Italian restaurants in St Augustine.

• Opening Hours: Sun – Thurs: 11 am – 10 pm, Fri & Sat: 11 am – 11 pm
• Location: 105 Yacht Club Dr, St. Augustine, FL 32084

6. Luigi’s Trattoria

Step into Luigi’s Trattoria and prepare to be enchanted by its warm ambiance and delectable Italian dishes. This family-owned gem combines traditional recipes with a creative twist, offering a menu that caters to every palate. Luigi’s Trattoria has everything from classic pasta dishes to wood-fired pizzas.

• Opening Hours: Daily from 11:30 am to 10:00 pm

7. Bella Italia

Bella Italia captures the essence of Italian cuisine with its charming decor and flavorful menu. Their extensive wine list perfectly complements the authentic Italian dishes crafted from fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

Whether you’re in the mood for homemade pasta or mouthwatering seafood, Bella Italia has something to satisfy every craving. However, Bella Italia also falls among the top Italian restaurants in St Augustine.

• Opening Hours: Daily from 5:00 pm to 9:00 pm

8. La Dolce Vita

Experience a slice of Italy at La Dolce Vita, a cozy restaurant in St. Augustine’s heart. Known for its warm hospitality and authentic flavors, this charming eatery offers an extensive menu featuring homemade pasta, savory risotto, and delightful tiramisu.

• Opening Hours: Tuesday to Sunday from 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm

9. Trattoria Ciao

Trattoria Ciao is a hidden gem that transports diners to the heart of Tuscany. This intimate eatery offers an array of Italian favorites, from hearty lasagna to tender osso buco.

Trattoria Ciao ranks ninth among the top Italian restaurants in St Augustine. With an inviting atmosphere and exceptional service, Trattoria Ciao is a must-visit for Italian food enthusiasts.

• Opening Hours: Tuesday to Sunday from 5:30 pm to 10:00 pm

10. Vesuvio Italian Restaurant

Located in a historic building, Vesuvio Italian Restaurant exudes elegance and charm. Their menu boasts a fusion of traditional and contemporary Italian dishes, expertly prepared using only the finest ingredients. Whether you’re craving Neapolitan pizza or homemade gnocchi, Vesuvio guarantees an unforgettable dining experience.

• Opening Hours: Daily from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm

Conclusion

Check out the article above to discover the ten top Italian restaurants in St Augustine with diverse menus and dining experiences. St Augustine boasts an impressive selection of Italian restaurants that promise to delight even the most discerning food enthusiasts. From cozy trattorias to elegant dining restaurants, each venue offers a unique culinary experience infused with the authentic flavors of Italy. Buon appetito!