10 Leading Italian Restaurants in Albany NY (2023)

If you’re craving the delicious tastes of Italy in Albany NY, you’re in luck! Albany is home to a remarkable selection of Italian restaurants that will transport your taste buds to the picturesque streets of Rome, the rolling hills of Tuscany, and the coastal towns of Sicily. This blog post will take you on a delightful journey through ten outstanding Italian restaurants in Albany NY. Get ready to savor traditional dishes, relish homemade pasta, and indulge in authentic flavors that will leave you wanting more.

Italian Restaurants in Albany NY

1. Rosanna’s

Rosanna’s, the newest restaurant in Albany’s Center Square neighborhood, is a delightful Italian eatery with a charming retro-glam ambiance. It pays homage to its predecessor, Bongiorno’s, and chef/owner, Rosanna Bongiorno.

The renovated historic building houses this Insta-worthy spot, serving a delicious menu of Old-World Italian dishes infused with a contemporary flair. From homemade pasta to mouthwatering pizza and small plates, Rosanna’s promises a memorable dining experience.

• Address: 23 Dove St, Albany, NY 12210, USA
• Phone: (518) 462-9176

2. D’Raymonds

D’Raymonds ranks second among the ten leading Italian restaurants in Albany NY. This restaurant is a beloved local restaurant in Loudonville. D’Raymonds has been a go-to spot since its restaurant in 1979. It has consistently won the “Best Italian Restaurant” award for 13 consecutive years in the Times Union’s reader’s choice poll.

With an extensive menu offering mouthwatering Italian dishes like pasta, chicken, veal, and fish, D’Raymonds is always bustling with customers. Due to its popularity, making reservations in advance is strongly advised.

3. Café Capriccio

Café Capricco is a renowned restaurant in Albany NY, known for its authentic Italian cuisine. They offer a diverse menu featuring house-made pasta, cured meats, cheeses, and delicious wood oven pizzas. The tagline “Albany’s Authentic Italian Table” aims to provide a romantic dining experience inspired by their numerous trips to Italy.

• Address: 49 Grand St, Albany, NY 12207, USA

4. Milano Restaurant

Milano Restaurant in Latham has been delighting diners with genuine Northern Italian cuisine since 1991. With a focus on quality, they make their pasta and wood-fired pizza from scratch every day.

However, Milano restaurant also falls among the ten leading Italian restaurants in Albany NY. The restaurant’s impressive wine selection and seasonal menu make it ideal for socializing with friends or having a romantic evening.

5. Nicole’s Restaurant

Nicole’s Restaurant, located on Delaware Avenue, is a charming family-owned restaurant known for its elegant Italian and contemporary American dishes. With a cozy dining room featuring a vintage tin ceiling, it’s an ideal setting for a romantic date night.

In the summertime, guests can escape the city’s chaos on the tranquil back deck. Whether you prefer savoring the Chef’s Specials outdoors or indulging in a refreshing fruity cocktail, Nicole’s offers a delightful dining experience.

• Address: 556 Delaware Ave, Albany, NY 12209, USA

6. Tesoro Restaurant

Tesoro Restaurant is one of the top Italian restaurants in Albany NY.  This restaurant is located in Guilderland on Western Avenue and is a cherished family-owned Italian eatery.

Founded in 2008 by Chef Raffaele Sainato and his sous chef, Abdullah Zinneddine, Tesoro Restaurant offers a diverse range of Italian dishes. With the name “Tesoro,” meaning “treasure,” the restaurant aims to showcase its deep appreciation for the culinary craft and its valued patrons.

7. Cardona’s Market

Cardona’s Market, a beloved Italian foods market in Albany’s Delaware Avenue neighborhood, is marking its 75th anniversary. The Cardona Family has been dedicated to providing top-notch Italian products for three generations.

Excitingly, Cardona’s Market has expanded by welcoming Roma Foods Importing Co.’s Latham and Saratoga locations into their family. With three convenient locations, customers can enjoy pre-packaged meals, fresh produce, cheese, olives, a wide selection of jarred specialty products, hot food items, and delicious new subs from the deli.

• Address: 340 Delaware Ave, Albany, NY 12209, USA

8. Anthony’s Italian Restaurant

Anthony’s Italian Restaurant is a new addition to Cohoes’ restaurant scene, offering classic Italian dishes with fresh pasta. Located on Remsen Street, the restaurant exudes old-school charm. Visitors can experience “Eat In The Street” on Friday nights during the summer or indulge in the weekend special on Saturdays. However, Anthony’s Italian ranks eighth among the top Italian restaurants in Albany NY.

• Address: 1475 Western Ave, Albany, NY 12203, USA

9. Valente’s Restaurant

Valente’s Restaurant, a beloved family-friendly Italian eatery in Watervliet, has been delighting customers with authentic recipes since 1958. Valente’s Restaurant is a local legend in the Capital Region, known for generous portions and mouthwatering dishes. Don’t forget to look for Valente’s Pasta Sauce, including Mariana, original, and vodka cream flavors, in nearby Price Choppers and Shop Rites.

10. Caffe Italia

Caffe Italia is a beloved Albany restaurant known for its authentic Italian cuisine. The menu offers many delicious dishes, including eggplant parmigiana, chicken marsala, and veal scalopini. Enjoy delightful desserts like Rita’s Lemon Ricotta Cheese Cake and Maria’s Key Lime Pie. Caffe Italia is located on Central Avenue and is a must-visit for those craving Old World classics.

• Address: 662 Central Ave, Albany, NY 12206, USA

Conclusion

Regarding Italian restaurants in Albany NY, these ten restaurants stand out as the crème de la crème. From family-owned gems to chic and modern eateries, each restaurant offers its unique charm and culinary excellence. So, the next time you’re in the mood for an authentic Italian dining experience, head to one of these exceptional restaurants and let your taste buds embark on a flavorsome journey through the heart of Italy.